Baby Shower Gift Basket Ideas [UNDER $100 + THEMED!]

Written by: Dalia Abdalla



Time to read 14 min

The Best Baby Shower Gift Basket Ideas

As a mom who's been through the joy of welcoming a new baby, I understand the excitement and anticipation that surrounds baby showers. In my latest blog post, I'm thrilled to share baby shower gift basket ideas that will surely make the mom-to-be feel special. From practical essentials to heartwarming personalized touches, these gift basket suggestions will help you celebrate the upcoming arrival in style.

1. Gift Basket For Girl

Wooden Crate

This is one of my favorite holders in this list. I really like the simplicity of the box itself. It can really fit into the neutral category as well because of the simple design. 

  1. Spacious: It's large enough to hold a variety of baby shower gifts, from baby clothes and blankets to toys and books.

  2. Durable: Made from sustainable pine wood, this crate is strong and durable, ensuring it will last long after the baby shower.

  3. Customization: You can get creative with decorating the crate to match the baby shower theme. Add ribbons, bows, or even paint it with baby-themed designs.

  4. Practicality: The crate can be used as nursery decor or storage, which is not only cute but also functional for the new parents.


I recommend including towels in a newborn baby shower gift basket because they're not only practical but also gentle on the baby's sensitive skin. 


Newborns can be messy, and soft, absorbent towels are perfect for cleaning up spills and keeping the little one dry. These baby towels are designed to be gentle, preventing any irritation or discomfort. 


Plus, they come in cute designs and can even be personalized, making them a thoughtful and adorable addition to any baby shower gift basket. 


  1. Gentle on Newborn Skin: These towels are soft and gentle, perfect for a baby's delicate skin.

  2. Machine Washable: Easy to clean, making them convenient for new parents.

  3. Durable: Withstand many washes without fraying, ensuring long-lasting use.

  4. Adorable Design: Featuring cute Crisp Blossom prints, adding charm to bath time.

  5. Value Pack: Comes in a set of three, offering practicality for everyday use.


Need Cute Baby Shower Invites? Check These Out!

Elephant Stuffed Animal

I highly recommend adding a cute elephant stuffed animal to a newborn baby shower gift basket because it's not just an adorable companion for the baby, but it also offers comfort and companionship during those early months. Babies often find comfort in snuggling with soft and huggable toys, and a sweet elephant plushie can become their new best friend.


  1. Softness and Cuddliness: This plush elephant is incredibly soft and huggable, making it the perfect companion for a newborn baby. Its plush velour ears and feet add to the overall comfort and snuggle factor.

  2. Baby Safe Design: One of the key features is its baby-safe design. It has embroidered black eyes and no hard pieces such as eyes or noses, ensuring that it's safe for even the youngest babies to cuddle and play with.

  3. Gender-Neutral Appeal: The gray color and adorable design of this elephant make it a gender-neutral gift, suitable for both baby boys and girls. This versatility ensures that it can be a thoughtful addition to any baby shower gift basket. 

New Born Shoes

These tiny shoes not only look incredibly cute but also serve a purpose as they protect the baby's delicate feet and keep them warm. They're a symbol of the baby's first steps in life and can be a cherished keepsake for the family. 

  1. Comfort and Safety: These shoes prioritize the baby's comfort and safety with a breathable lining and skin-friendly materials, which are crucial for a newborn's delicate skin.

  2. Supportive Soles: The soft, lightweight, and anti-slip soles offer a natural walking experience and aid in the baby's development as they take their first steps.

  3. Easy to Wear: The hook and loop design ensures easy on-and-off for parents, and they stay securely on the baby's feet.

  4. Adorable Design: The cute bowknot and princess-style design make these shoes perfect for special occasions or everyday wear, adding to the baby's charm.


Not only do these tiny accessories look absolutely adorable on newborns, but they're also great for keeping wispy baby hair out of their eyes. Headbands are versatile, and you can find a variety of colors and designs to match different outfits. They add an extra layer of charm to the baby's appearance and make for precious photo opportunities.

  1. Variety of Colors: These baby headbands come in a set of 12 delightful colors, from classic pastels to vibrant hues. This variety allows parents to mix and match the headbands with their baby's outfits, adding a touch of style and cuteness to any look.

  2. Comfort and Softness: The headbands are crafted from exceptionally soft and stretchy nylon material, which is perfect for a baby's delicate skin. They are so comfortable that your little one won't even feel them, ensuring a fuss-free experience.

  3. Gentle on Baby's Skin: Designed with the baby's comfort in mind, these headbands won't leave any unsightly marks on the baby's head. This feature is especially important for newborns who have sensitive skin, making them a safe choice.

  4. One-Size-Fits-All: The headbands boast excellent elasticity, ensuring a secure fit for newborns, infants, toddlers, and even adults. This means they will grow with the baby, providing a comfortable fit throughout their early years. 


In my experience as a parent, I can't stress enough how essential onesies are for newborns, which is why they're a must-have in any baby shower gift basket. These one-piece wonders are not only incredibly convenient for diaper changes but also super cozy for a baby's delicate skin. With a wide range of cute prints and patterns available, you can add a touch of personal flair to your gift.

  1. Practicality: These Sleep 'N Play Footies are essential for newborns. They are comfortable and versatile, perfect for both daytime and nighttime wear. Parents will appreciate having multiple onesies on hand for quick changes, especially during those early days of frequent diaper changes.

  2. Soft and Gentle: Made of 100% cotton, these footies are incredibly soft and gentle on a baby's delicate skin. Newborns have sensitive skin, and having soft clothing options is a must to ensure their comfort.

  3. Easy Dressing: The front zipper opening makes dressing and changing the baby a breeze. It's a thoughtful feature that new parents will find convenient, especially during late-night diaper changes when every second counts.

  4. Variety: This 4-pack offers a variety of adorable designs and colors, such as Bunny Pink. It adds a touch of cuteness to the baby's wardrobe, and parents will appreciate having different options to dress their little one in.

Need nursery stationery?

2. Unisex Gift Baskets

Teether Toy Rattle

I wholeheartedly recommend adding a teeth rattle to a baby shower gift basket. This delightful toy not only keeps the baby engaged and entertained but also serves a purpose. As those tiny teeth start to make their debut, a teeth rattle provides much-needed relief from teething discomfort

  1. Safe and Natural Materials: This teether toy is made from natural untreated beech wood and soft crochet, making it a safe and eco-friendly choice for babies.

  2. Sensory Stimulation: The toy offers various textures and surfaces for babies to touch and feel, helping them develop their sense of touch and enhance motor skills.

  3. Entertainment: The rattle inside the toy provides entertainment for babies with its gentle noise, keeping them engaged and delighted.

  4. Teething Relief: Babies can chew on the crochet parts and the wooden ring, providing soothing relief during the teething process.

Chewy Teething Toys

I can't emphasize enough how much I love the Moonkie Stacks of Circles Soft Teething Toy for a baby shower gift basket. This cleverly designed teething toy is not only incredibly cute but also provides much-needed relief for those sore gums. The soft, textured rings are perfect for little ones to chew on and explore with their fingers, helping to soothe discomfort during teething. 

  1. Safe and Non-Toxic: This teething toy is made of high-quality food-grade silicone, which means it's safe for babies to play with and chew on. It doesn't contain any harmful chemicals like BPA or Phthalates.

  2. Encourages Development: The toy is not just for teething; it's also a fun educational tool. Babies can learn to stack the rings, which helps develop their fine and gross motor skills. It also improves their problem-solving and hand-eye coordination abilities.

  3. Versatile Teether: It serves as a soft and soothing teether for babies. The material is gentle on their gums, providing relief during teething discomfort.

Carrot Crochet Toy

This adorable and lovingly crafted rattle is not only visually appealing but also provides a delightful sensory experience for little ones. The soft, crochet design is perfect for tiny hands to grasp, and the gentle rattle sound is captivating for babies. It's a wonderful combination of both a toy and a teether, making it a thoughtful addition to help soothe those teething gums. 

  1. This cute Carrot Rattle is soft and easy for little hands to hold. Babies love to grab and play with it.

  2. The bright colors and inviting texture of the rattle can help stimulate a baby's senses and keep them engaged.

  3. It's made from 100% organically grown bamboo yarn, which is a safe and eco-friendly material for babies.


Lined Wicker Basket

I absolutely adore the cute white-lined wicker basket I've chosen for my baby gift basket ideas. It's not just any ordinary basket; it adds a delightful touch to the overall presentation of the gift. Here's why I think this basket is absolutely adorable: 

  1. Charming Design: The white-painted wicker basket has a rustic and vintage charm that can add a touch of elegance to any baby shower decor. Its aesthetic appeal makes it a visually pleasing gift.

  2. Versatility: This basket is versatile and can be used for various purposes, making it a practical gift. It can hold baby essentials like diapers, baby clothes, blankets, and toys, or even serve as a decorative piece in the nursery.

  3. Removable Liner: The included lace-trimmed fabric liner is not only adorable but also removable and washable. It adds a soft and cozy touch to the basket, making it perfect for baby items.

  4. Ample Size: With dimensions of 13 x 10 x 6 inches, this basket offers ample space for storing a variety of baby shower gifts. It can accommodate both small and large items, making it suitable for any gift selection. 

3. Gift Basket For Boy

Rectangular Wicker Basket

I love this for its unique shape, modern appeal, practicality, and reusability make it a delightful addition to any baby gift ensemble. It combines aesthetic charm with functionality, making it a top-notch choice for creating an adorable and memorable baby gift basket.

  1. Size and Capacity: With dimensions of 18" x 12.5" x 9.5", this wooden crate offers ample space to accommodate a variety of baby shower gifts, including baby clothes, blankets, diapers, and toys. Its generous size ensures that you can include a range of practical and meaningful items.

  2. Durability: Crafted from natural pine wood, this crate is not only aesthetically pleasing but also sturdy and durable. It can withstand the wear and tear that comes with daily use in a nursery, making it a long-lasting gift for the new parents.

  3. Sustainability: The crate is made from sustainable forest sources, making it an eco-friendly choice. This aligns with environmentally conscious values and sets a positive example for the baby's future.

Clothing Set

The baby boy clothes I've handpicked for this gift basket are nothing short of adorable. Here's why they're an essential addition:

  1. Charming Designs: These clothes feature charming designs that are tailor-made for newborn boys. From tiny animal prints to playful patterns and cute graphics, they're visually captivating and sure to make anyone smile.

  2. Soft and Cozy Fabrics: Quality matters, especially for delicate newborn skin. These clothes are crafted from soft, breathable fabrics that ensure the baby's comfort and coziness all day long. They are gentle to the touch, making them perfect for a newborn's sensitive skin.

  3. Practicality: While cuteness is essential, these clothes are also highly practical. They include essential items like onesies, sleepers, and bodysuits, all of which are crucial for a newborn's wardrobe. Parents will appreciate having these basics readily available.

Boat Ship Steering Wheel

The boat steering wheel toy I've carefully selected for this baby boy gift basket is not just cute; it's a fantastic addition for several reasons:

Nautical Theme: The boat steering wheel perfectly aligns with a nautical theme, which is not only charming but also a classic choice for baby boys. It adds a touch of seaside adventure to the gift, making it stand out.

Imaginative Play: This toy encourages imaginative play. As the baby grows, they'll love pretending to be a little captain steering their ship on exciting adventures. It sparks creativity and offers hours of entertainment.

Tactile Stimulation: The steering wheel features various textures and shapes, which are essential for a baby's sensory development. Babies can explore these tactile elements with their tiny hands, promoting sensory awareness.


Below Are Essential You Should Include:

  • Diapers: A supply of diapers is always appreciated, as newborns go through them quickly. You can include a variety of sizes to ensure they're covered as the baby grows.

  • Baby Wipes: Wipes are essential for quick clean-ups and diaper changes. Opt for hypoallergenic and fragrance-free wipes for sensitive baby skin.

  • Onesies/Bodysuits: These one-piece garments are easy to put on and take off, making them a staple in a baby's wardrobe.

  • Swaddle Blankets: Swaddle blankets are versatile and can be used for swaddling, as a nursing cover, or as a lightweight stroller blanket.

  • Baby Clothes: Include a selection of baby outfits, such as sleepers, rompers, and baby socks, suitable for various weather conditions.

  • Baby Toiletries: Baby shampoo, baby lotion, and baby wash are useful additions. Look for products with gentle and natural ingredients.

  • Baby Bibs: Bibs help keep baby's clothing clean during feedings and prevent drool from soaking through.

  • Pacifiers: Pacifiers can provide comfort to fussy babies. Make sure to choose ones that are age-appropriate and meet safety standards.

  • Baby Bottles and Formula: If the parents are formula-feeding, including a few bottles and formula can be a great help.

  • Baby Thermometer: A digital thermometer designed for infants is essential for monitoring the baby's temperature.

  • Baby Nail Clippers/Scissors: Baby nails can grow quickly, and a pair of baby-safe nail clippers or scissors can prevent accidental scratching.

  • Burp Cloths: These are handy for protecting parents' clothing from spit-up during burping sessions.

  • Baby Blankets: Soft, cozy baby blankets can provide warmth and comfort for the baby during naps and bedtime.

  • Diaper Rash Cream: Include a gentle diaper rash cream to help prevent and treat diaper rash.

  • Baby Towels and Washcloths: Hooded baby towels and soft washcloths are useful for bath time.

  • Baby Book: A board book with colorful pictures can be a delightful addition to encourage early reading habits.

  • Baby Toys: Simple, age-appropriate toys, such as soft rattles or teething toys, can entertain and stimulate a baby's senses.

  • Gift Cards: If you're unsure about specific preferences or sizes, a gift card to a baby store can be a practical option.

  • Parenting Books: Consider adding a parenting book that provides helpful tips and guidance for new parents. 

Click Below To Shop For The Essentials!

FAQ Section

How do you fill a baby shower gift basket?

To fill a baby shower gift basket, start by selecting a suitable basket or container. Then, consider the preferences and needs of the expecting parents. Include a mix of baby essentials such as diapers, onesies, swaddle blankets, baby toiletries, baby bibs, and baby toys. You can also add a personal touch with a handwritten card or note. Customize the contents based on the baby's gender, the theme of the baby shower, and your budget.

What amount should I spend on a baby shower gift?

The amount you should spend on a baby shower gift can vary depending on your relationship with the parents and your budget. Typically, spending between $20 to $50 is considered a standard range for baby shower gifts. However, feel free to adjust the amount based on your personal circumstances and how close you are to the expecting parents.

What sort of things do you buy for a baby shower?

Common items to buy for a baby shower include baby clothes, diapers, baby wipes, baby toiletries, baby blankets, baby toys, and practical baby gear like bottles and pacifiers. You can also consider specialty items like personalized baby items, nursery decor, or gift cards to baby stores.

What do you get expecting parents for a baby shower?

When selecting a baby shower gift for expecting parents, focus on items that will be useful for them and the baby. Think about essentials like baby clothing, diapering supplies, baby gear, and nursery items. Gifts that provide comfort and convenience for new parents are often appreciated.

How do you arrange a baby gift basket?

To arrange a baby gift basket, start by placing a layer of tissue paper or fabric at the bottom of the basket for padding and decoration. Then, arrange the larger items at the back, leaning against the sides of the basket. Fill the center with smaller items, ensuring they are visible and accessible. Add any decorative elements, such as ribbons or bows, to enhance the presentation.

What do you put in a baby shower box?

A baby shower box can contain similar items to a gift basket, but they are packed in a box rather than a basket. You can include baby clothes, baby essentials, baby accessories, and a heartfelt card or note. Customize the contents based on the theme of the baby shower and the parents' preferences.

Who pays for baby shower stuff?

Traditionally, baby showers are hosted and organized by friends or family members of the expecting parents, and they typically cover the expenses for the baby shower. However, the specifics can vary depending on cultural traditions and individual arrangements. Sometimes, guests may also contribute to the costs by bringing food or gifts.

Do dads pay for baby shower?

The responsibility for paying for a baby shower traditionally falls on the host or hosts, who are often friends or family members of the expecting parents. While dads may participate in planning or contributing to the baby shower, they are not typically expected to cover the entire cost themselves. The financial arrangements can vary based on individual preferences and cultural norms.


Modern Pink Paper Author - Dalia Abdalla

Dalia Abdalla

Owner & Head Designer, Modern Pink Paper

Dalia is the creative force behind Modern Pink Paper. With a keen eye for detail and a love for all things stationery, she embarked on this journey to provide personalized stationery solutions. When she's not crafting beautiful paper creations, Dalia is sharing her insights and inspirations on this blog, ensuring that her readers always have a touch of beauty and creativity in their lives.